For 90 years, the name of the writer McGraw-Hill, rendered in intricate Art Deco terra-cotta lettering, has adorned the crown of the eponymous blue-green modernist constructing on West forty second Avenue, which rose above a scraggly tenement neighborhood throughout the Nice Melancholy.
Even after the company left within the early Nineteen Seventies for a skyscraper at forty eighth Avenue and the Avenue of the Americas, the name continued to embroider the Hell’s Kitchen skyline. The constructing was designated a city landmark in 1979, and simply final yr a restoration of the 35-story tower’s distinctive terra-cotta cladding gained an award from the New York Landmarks Conservancy, which praised the way the “11-foot-tall Deco style ‘McGraw-Hill’ sign was stripped to reveal the preserved original glaze.”
But on Jan. 13, Deco Tower Associates, the constructing’s proprietor, introduced a proposal to take away the name from the crown and substitute it with “330 W 42nd St” — a designation that doesn’t precisely roll off the tongue. Though the address was to be rendered in the identical model and materials because the name it was supposed to exchange, the Land Use Committee of Community Board 4 was stunned by the plan, which it unanimously opposed.
In response to the brewing controversy, the proprietor eliminated the crown signage change from the alteration proposal introduced to the city Landmarks Preservation Commission on Feb. 9. As part of the tower’s redevelopment into modern office space designed by MdeAS Architects, the proprietor nonetheless plans to add the address to the forty second Avenue entrance. Each the commission and the community board unanimously accepted that change.
“A lot of what historic preservation is about is trying to find the balance between the tangible fabric and the intangible fabric of a building, and names and signs are very much getting into that territory,” Invoice Higgins, the project’s preservation consultant, said in an interview.
“The intangible is: What’s the name of the building? What is its identity? Is it still thought of as the Chrysler Building,” Mr. Higgins said, even after Chrysler is gone? “Is it still thought of as the Pan Am Building when there is no Pan Am? Is it the McGraw-Hill Building when there still is a McGraw Hill, but it’s in a different place?”
Within the case of the McGraw-Hill Constructing, the intangible id is tangibly integrated into the very masonry of its north and south facades, in an uncommonly outstanding method. And for some neighborhood residents, the sturdiness of the terra-cotta name on that crown helps impart a reassuring fidelity to the constructing, making it really feel like a dependable old pal in an ever-changing cityscape.
“On 9/11, McGraw-Hill, staring at that from my rooftop on 47th Street was something that didn’t change,” Christopher LeBrón, a community board member, said on the public meeting. “And it means a lot to this community.”
Based in 1917, the McGraw-Hill Publishing Company purchased land in 1930 for a new headquarters at forty second Avenue west of Eighth Avenue. To design it, James McGraw employed Raymond Hood, a nimble architectural provocateur whose neo-Gothic entry had gained the design competitors for the Chicago Tribune Tower. In New York, Hood left his mark with such various initiatives because the Each day News Constructing and the dazzling, Gothic-inspired American Radiator Constructing.
His McGraw-Hill Constructing was a strikingly spare and colourful modernist skyscraper that loomed over its hardscrabble, low-rise neighborhood. Incorporating parts of the European-born International Fashion, the tower asserted a daring horizontality, ribbons of tall, factory-style home windows alternating with eye-catching blue-green bands of terra cotta.
The flamboyant edifice provoked suspicious harrumphs from conservative critics, however Henry-Russell Hitchcock and Philip Johnson, who disdained applied ornament, admired it sufficient to incorporate it of their influential Museum of Fashionable Art exhibition and book “The International Style.”
Their main quibble? “The heavy ornamental crown,” with its intricate interaction of colours and planes, which they deemed “an illogical and unhappy break in the general system of regularity.”
However these crinkled noses had been a light response in comparison with the cri de coeur the tower’s crown aroused amongst those that made their residing constructing indicators.
“Who will control the sign industry of the future — the advertising man, architect or mason?” requested Indicators of the Times, a trade magazine. “When the light of neon wanes in the advertisers’ eyes, will this type of display take its place … floodlighted in symphonies of brilliance and color to make our cities stare and admire?”
Produced by the Federal Seaboard Terra Cotta Corporation from plaster molds, the main body of every handmade letter was composed of white terra-cotta blocks that protruded six inches from a starkly contrasting blue-green background. Shipped from the manufacturing facility packed in hay, the items of this big jigsaw puzzle had been sorted on the job web site.
“It’s totally unique, or almost totally unique,” said Thomas E. Rinaldi, an indication historian and the creator of “New York Neon.”
On the community board listening to, the constructing proprietor’s representatives argued that there was precedent for changing a landmark’s outstanding signage, however their examples had been simply detachable indicators not physically integrated right into a constructing the way the McGraw-Hill name is.
“I do not accept that it’s just an ephemeral sign, perishable in the way we accept signs as being perishable,” Mr. Rinaldi said in an interview. “I think it’s completely irrelevant to the conversation whether McGraw-Hill even still exists, much less whether they’re still in the building. To me, it’s more akin to something inscribed in the entablature of a portico than to neon letters mounted onto a metal armature on a roof.”
The landmarks commission has beforehand accepted the replacement of corporate indicators on high-profile landmarks, however none concerned a name embedded into an edifice’s construction at a scale corresponding to that of the McGraw-Hill Constructing.
The crown of 30 Rockefeller Plaza, an Art Deco tower designed by Hood, was initially adorned with the name of Rockefeller Center’s largest tenant, RCA, the 24-foot-high letters manufactured from tubes stuffed with glowing amber fuel. First illuminated in 1937, the RCA indicators (they appeared on three sides) had been changed in 1969 with the identical letters in a mod new design.
In 1985, Rockefeller Center, of which 30 Rock is the centerpiece, was given landmark status, and in 1989, after General Electrical swallowed up RCA, the commission allowed the three letters on the constructing’s crown to get replaced with two: GE.
In 2013, Comcast purchased GE’s stake in NBCUniversal, a deal that included naming rights to 30 Rock. The commission then accepted the replacement of the GE indicators with LED-illuminated signage: NBC’s multicolored peacock brand on one elevation and the name Comcast topped with the emblem on two others.
The Germania Life Insurance Constructing, at 50 Union Sq. East, has additionally worn varied hats. Initially an indication bearing the phrases Germania Life adorned its mansard roof. After anti-German sentiment sparked by World War I induced a name change to Guardian Life, the signage modified accordingly. The constructing turned a landmark in 1988, and in 2000 the city permitted the phrases on the roof to be modified to the lodge name W Union Sq. in letters “of the same size, color and font.”
After USA News Hunt left its longtime home at 229 West forty third Avenue in 2007, the phrase Times was stripped from the landmark’s tower, and in 2014 the city accepted the set up of purple indicators displaying the name Yahoo!
One of many more delicate changes to a well-known city constructing’s integrated signage occurred at 230 Park Avenue, which straddles the avenue at forty sixth Avenue. Inbuilt 1929 for the New York Central Railroad, the ornate tower initially bore the carved phrases New York Central Constructing above its entrance. However when the construction was leased in 1958 to Irving Brodsky, it was rechristened The New York General Constructing, a name chosen, Mr. Brodsky said, as a result of it required the alteration of only two letters “chiseled in granite on the building.”
The edifice was given landmark safety in 1987, however not earlier than it was acquired by Harry Helmsley, who eliminated the phrases and splashed the name The Helmsley Constructing throughout the facade in Trumpian gold letters.
Proper upstairs, hulking above 230 Park, is the obtrusive and unloved skyscraper inbuilt 1963 for Pan American World Airways. For 3 many years the name Pan Am, rendered in aluminum and neon, was affixed to the tower’s top, one of the seen indicators the city has ever recognized.
Pan Am went bankrupt in 1991, and when the constructing’s proprietor, the Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, introduced plans to change the tower’s name, the architect Robert A.M. Stern requested cheekily, “Couldn’t they just leave the sign up and take the building down?”
However the tower has now worn its “new” name practically so long as it wore its old one, and to a generation of New Yorkers who had been born or arrived right here because the early Nineteen Nineties, the constructing is named the MetLife.
Nonetheless, buildings’ identities die exhausting in New Yorkers’ hearts.
“You are a New Yorker when what was there before is more real and solid than what is here now,” Colson Whitehead, a city native, wrote in his 2004 book “The Colossus of New York.” “I still call it the Pan Am Building, not out of affectation, but because that’s what it is.”
For weekly email updates on residential actual estate news, enroll right here. Follow us on Twitter: @nytrealestate.